Domestic Holocaust
Jonathon Taylor’s adaptation of the novel by Martin Amis is a cold affair. Cold, chilling and hard work.
Filmed as if it was a fly on the wall documentary we follow the everyday life of Hedwig Hoss ( Sandra Hüller) the wife of Auschwitz Commander Rudolph( Christian Friedel) who runs her household of five children, maids and gardeners in a well appointed modern town house, feet from the concentration camp wall. Her house and particularly her garden is her pride and joy, and it is soon apparent that the war and her marriage has elevated her in rank and privilege to become the self proclaimed “Queen of Auschwitz “
We see very little of the camp itself , save for the fire in the sky chimneys of the crematoria, casting light and noise in the night like something from Tolkien .
But we hear it.
The factory hum of machinery and traffic, the constant shootings and occasional screams , this is the backdrop to a horror ignored by Hedwig who raises her family in the Hitler Way, with good food, exercise, fresh air and country pursuits .
The negative effects of living such a life is lost on the adults but we glimpse how the children have reacted. One sleep walks nightly, another collects human teeth, two others swim in the river and are covered in human remains and have to scrubbed in the kitchen sink whilst another boy, rather heartbreakingly listens passively as a prisoner is drowned by guards for not following orders.
Only one person is shown to acknowledge the horror of the Hoss’ new life and that is Hedwig’s mother who leaves the family home in the middle of the night to escape the world beyond the garden wall.
This is a hard watch. The actors are given little to soften their characters and the sounds of the camp never leave the narrative and wear you down by the end the film.
The trailer for this was shown at the cinema yesterday aptly just after an appeal for Holocaust Memorial Day Trust appeal which of course is today.
ReplyDeleteThe film looked bleak beyond words.
I was there to see All of Us Strangers with the sublime Andrew Scott. Fabulous film would highly recommend.
It’s on my list lizzie.
DeleteThis film, is an important take on the Holocaust and is one everyone should see, although it’s pace , long use of takes , and confusing narrative ( at times) would put some younger people off
It beggars belief that someone could endeavour to lead an idyllic life with the horrors of a concentration camp so close.
ReplyDeleteIt surely was not her choice. Nor could it be anyone's.
DeleteI have to believe these acts were pure evil . No human with a heart could be so.
I think it’s much more complicated and insidious ( yes the proper use of the word) dialogue between Hedwig and her mother alluded to their poor early days and that depression post ww1 was important in dissatisfaction of many in Germany against the Jews
DeleteThank you for the review! I mean to see One Life soon, and it looks like The Zone of Interest is playing here too. I'm not exposed to many ads, so your reviews have sent me looking for movies that I'd not otherwise have known existed.
ReplyDeleteThe Homeovers is the lightest of my recent review
DeleteHaving toured a concentration camp in Czechoslovakia and taken a water aerobics class with a holocaust survivor, and seeing the numbers tattooed on her arm, I just know that I could not sit through that film. The camp we toured had a swimming pool for the use of the guards! Gigi
ReplyDeleteIt was Theresienstadt, I’ve been there
DeleteYes thats it
DeleteI was destroyed walking around it
DeleteThank you for the review. Heartbreaking and chilling.
ReplyDeleteAlison in Wales x
It reinforced how well humans can deceive themselves
DeleteAnd yet, here we are once again, all of us, averting our eyes. These movies are heartbreaking but necessary. Debby
DeleteYour review sends chills down my spine. I know I couldn't watch it - I'd be a sobbing wreck. That sounds so trite, given what the camp prisoners endured. If only people learned from history, but sadly, the world seems to want to repeat such horrors.
ReplyDeleteI doubt you would react in that way . The violence , and indeed the Jewish prisoners themselves were never seen on film
DeleteHard to watch, important to remember, and prevent from happening.
ReplyDeleteI would have liked a study of the family AFTER the war, and their reflections and explainstions
DeleteHorrifying, but an apt analogy for our times. And for our ability to live in denial and ignore the suffering of others, especially if their suffering provides the material comforts of our lifestyle.
ReplyDeleteNicely put , apathy and denial go hand in hand
DeleteI can't watch anything Holocaust-related anymore. It hurts and angers and upsets far too much. Is there more to be learned from the true stories? I don't know. Only that I can't go there these days. I appreciate that you do, and share; I don't forget, but there is only so much my heart can take. -Kate
ReplyDeleteUnderstood…and noted
DeleteThis has a spin on the usual suspects
Often the world seems crazy, John.
ReplyDeleteEvery day
DeleteThe small rural town my parents lived in had a Saturday market and Id go on the bus with my mum we’d get groceries and I would look at the stalls. It was the early 50’s I was 11 we had no tv then and I picked up a paperback on the second hand book stall it was about the concentration camps. I remember being stunned and horrified and asking my mum is this true and of course she told me it was true. Jean
ReplyDeleteI’m sure news was not as prompt and everyday as it is today but concentration camps were rife
Delete“ Nazi officials established more than 44,000 incarceration sites during the time of the Third Reich. This estimate is based on continuing research of contemporary sources, including the perpetrators’ own records.“
So many ?
DeleteThat’s sobering
Keith
Xx
Indeed xx
DeleteSuch films are essential whilst there are still morons who deny the Holocaust ever happened, and anti Semitism is on the rise. And today is Holocaust Memorial Day so I shall join the world by putting a candle in my window at 8p.m.
ReplyDeleteI’ve lit my candle
DeleteYou are tougher than I am, John. I don't think I could stand to watch it. Too much hurt, profound sadness, and anger.
ReplyDeleteAfter an hour, to be honest, I had got the gist, and had had enough
DeleteThis is one film, book, or story I will never watch or read or listen to. I don't need that in my head. As a child, I read The Diary of Anne Frank and it broke my h heart.. I can take blood and gut in sugery and broken bones that aren't in proper alignment, but no thank you to that truth about man's inhuumanity to other people.
ReplyDeleteI believe positive creativeity and kindness will help the world we live in - if only.
Hugs!
This goes a little way of documenting what the ordinary Germans may of acted though I think I would like to think there were more jHedwig’s mother types around
DeleteYou have to be in the mood. As a film, it has a profound message
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteOn rereading, I see it is based on a novel. [I had asked/ deleted if this is a documentary.]
ReplyDeleteIt felt very matter of fact like a documentary
DeleteHorrifying. I can't imagine watching it myself but more power to those who can be informed/enlightened.
ReplyDeleteCeci
Many thousands looked away ceri
DeleteWe can’t do that hard as it is x
I'm on the final pages of a book that probably explains the behaviour shown in this film: 'A Village in the Third Reich' , how the ordinary lives were changed beyond recognition by Fascism. Inch by inch it is so mundane, much like the boiling frog analogy. (Is it happening now?)
ReplyDeleteThe other thing to consider is 'Befehl ist befehl', also still seen.
Winston Churchill's quote about history, (not the misquoted version), must be noted.
I live in hope
An order is an order…ah I see
DeleteI agree with many of the John that this would be too hard a watch,especially for older people with too much to remember. However we need to not forget.
ReplyDeleteAbout 15 years ago the High Schools of the town in Scotland I lived in,Kirkcaldy, sent some senior pupils on a visit to Auschwitz and on their return they put on a performance in the local theatre telling us about it. They invited Anne Frank's cousin Benny Frank and he came from Switzerland to speak to us because he said it was so good young people were still made aware. We spoke to him the next day and the saddest thing he said was that his family tried to persuade the Franks to come to Switzerland with them but they chose Holland because it was easier to get to. So sad.
I had a conversation with a dear showbiz friend tonight , he bemoaned the fact that lots of younger people don’t know who ELIZABETH TAYLOR was
DeletePeople forget
People will forget the Holocaust if allowed
I have recently been pondering my youth. My grade school class had lots of Jewish kids, and I spent a lot of time in their homes. It was the early 60s, and when I consider how soon after the war this was, I am astounded that none of their parents ever uttered one word to us about the war. I also remember reading a book about WWII just after college and I learned one more fact that just crushed me. I don't think I could stand watching this movie, but I am grateful that it has been made and hope that lots of young people who need to understand will see it.
ReplyDeleteNina
And frightened as they were, why would they say anything
DeleteI totally agree that would be why they wouldn't have wanted to discuss it. I am thinking, though, what a kindness it was for them to leave us kids in our little bubble for a little while longer. Junior high and its history classes were on the horizon, so our time to learn about it was not far off.
DeleteNina
I do not think I will be watching this film. It is horrifying that people can live comfortably while just down the street mass persecution and elimination of human life takes place.
ReplyDeleteWe need to understand why this happens
DeletePerhaps the work of Gordon Allport might help us understand why this happened.
ReplyDeletehttps://academic.oup.com/book/5539/chapter-abstract/148474923?redirectedFrom=fulltext
DeleteJohn, you are in an enviable position of having access to so many films. Your reviews call my attention to films I would otherwise never have heard of. Thanks for that!
ReplyDeleteI will try and see this movie.
ReplyDeleteThe problem is that the people who should watch films like that don´t do it. Or, like the immigrants from muslim countries to Germany, say that it has nothing to do with them, it is not thier history.
ReplyDeleteA few days ago, I watched the film The Children of Windermere, about a g some hundred children who had survived the holocaust and had been invited to England to get over their horrible time in the concentration camps. It was hard to watch, but also full of hope and kindness. At the end, there were five old men, who really had been in Windermere as kids and told about their life, and this was the moment when I could not hold back my tears.
Hilde in Germany
I've not heard of this film, and would probably find it very hard to watch. There are so many things we should all know about those camps, and also things we'd rather not. The concentration camps, and the Japanese treatment of the Chinese, show humanity at its very worst.
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like a hard watch, but one that should be watched, even in secondary schools. This chapter in our past should never be forgotten and seeing different perspectives on it can only be a good thing.
ReplyDelete